Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout080805 OTLRB Agenda In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please contact the office of the City Clerk (951) 694-6444. Notification 48 hours prior to a meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to that meeting [28 CFR 35.102.35.104 ADA Title IIJ AGENDA A REGULAR MEETING OF THE OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD MAIN CONFERENCE ROOM 43200 BUSINESS PARK DRIVE August 8, 2005 - 9:00 A.M. ********* CALL TO ORDER RollCall: Board Members: Allen, Harker, Haserot, Moore and Chairman Blair Alternate Board Member: Perkins . PUBLIC COMMENTS A total of 15 minutes is provided so members of the public. may address the Board on items that are listed on the Agenda. Speakers are limited to three (3) minutes each. If' you desire to speak to the Commission about an item not on the Agenda, a green "Request to Speak" form should be filled out and filed with the Board Secretary. When you are called to speak, please come forward and state your name for the record. For all other agenda items a "Request to Speak" form must be filed with the Board Secretary prior to the Commission addressing that item. There is a three (3) minute time limit for individual speakers. CONSENT CALENDAR NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC All matter listed under Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and all will be enacted by one roll call vote. There will be no discussion of these items unless member of the Local Review Board request specific items to be removed from the Consent Calendar for separate action. 1 Minutes RECOMMENDATION: . 1.1 Approve the Minutes of July 11 , 2005 R:\Old TownlAgendas\2005\OB-OB-05 OTLRB Agenda.doc NEW ITEMS 2 PlanninQ Application No. PA05-0148 An Administrative Development Plan to construct a new outdoor wine Qarden to be located in the lot to the north of the Palomar Hotel at the corner of OldTown Front Street and Fifth Street. Applicant: Mr. Carlos Palma Temecula House of Wine 28522 Old Town Front Street Temecula, CA 92590 Staff: Harmony Bales, Assistant Planner BOARD BUSINESS Swearing in of John R. Williams, Alternate DIRECTOR OF PLANNING REPORT DIRECTOR OF REDEVELOPMENT REPORT CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT BOARD MEMBER REPORT ADJOURNMENT Next meeting: September 12, 2005, 9:00 A.M., Main Conference Room, City Hall, 43200 Business Park Drive, Temecula, CA 92590 R:\Old TownlAgendas\2005\OB-DB-05 OTLRB Agenda.doc 2 . . . . . ITEM #1 . . . . , MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING OF THE OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD JULY 11, 2005 CALL TO ORDER The Old Town Temecula Local Review Board convened in a regular meeting at 9:00 a.m., on Monday, July 11, 2005, in the Main Conference Room, of Temecula City Hall, 43200 Business Park Drive, Temecula, California. ROLL CALL Present: Board Members Allen, Harker, Haserot, Moore, and Chairman Blair Absent: None. Also Present: Management Analyst Hillberg Director of Redevelopment Meyer Associate Planner Fisk Principal Planner Hazen Minute Clerk Childs PUBLIC COMMENTS No public comment. CONSENT CALENDAR 1 Minutes RECOMMENDATION: 1.1 Approve the Minutes of June 13, 2005. 1.2 Approve the Minutes of June 27, 2005. MOTION: Board member Moore moved to approve the Consent Calendar. Board Member Haserot seconded the motion and voice vote reflected unanimous approval. NEW ITEMS 2 Plannino Application No. PA05-0111 A Minor Modification to a Development Plan to add perimeter fencino and siqnaqe to the Shire Buildino. located at 28656 Old Town Front Street. oenerallv located at the southeast corner of Old Town Front Street and Main Street. Applicant: Mr. Richard Leigh 39554 Corte Gata Murrieta, CA 92562 R:/OldTownlLRB/Minutes/071105 Associate Planner Fisk presented the Board with a staff report (of written material). Mr. Robert Leigh noted his opposition for pedestrians using his property as a pathway, stating that he would prefer to iutilize his square footage for the display of products. . After much discussion with the applicant, it was the consensus of the Board to approve the following: . That a separate building permit be required for all signage .. That a corner treatment consist of a trellis structure or archway with a solid base, subject to approval by the Director of Planning, shall be incorporated into the southwest corner of the project site and shall be shown on the site plan. A detailed elevation for this structure shall also be shown on the site plan . That a fence be located along the property line at Old Town Front Street and Main Street shall not exceed a height of four feet. This site plan shall indicate the height of the fence and shall indicate that the fence is to be constructed of stucco pilasters with concrete caps and wrought iron . That a third pedestrian ingress/egress point shall be incorporated into the fence along the southern property line to allow unobstructed pedestrian access to the pedestrian accessible area adjoining the project site . Concrete area within the fenced yard area shall be minimized to include a four foot wide accessible path of travel for persons with disabilities using a wheelchair and that is also safe for the usable by persons with other disabilities. Up to four feet of concrete shall also be permitted at the perimeter of the building. The surface for all other areas within the fenced yard area shall be decomposed granite or other suitable material, subject to review and approval with the Director of Planning . . That site plan shall indicate that concrete in the fenced yard area shall be stamped concrete at the entries and colored concrete (ie., San Diego Butt) for all other concrete areas . That landscaping shall be added at the base of the building at the Old Town Front Street and Main Street elevations. This landscaping may be provided in contained planters of various shapes and sizes located adjacent. to the building, subject to review and approval by the Director of Planning. BOARD BUSINESS DIRECTOR OF PLANNING REPORT No report given. DIRECTOR OF REDEVELOPMENT REPORT Director of Redevelopment Meyer noted that fabrication has begun for a new store front at the . Mercantile Building. R:/OldTownlLRBlMinutes/071105 2 . CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT No report given. BOARD MEMBER REPORT Board Member Allen relayed his disappointment with the outcome of Item. No.2. ADJOURNMENT At 10:40 a.m., Board Member Blair formally adjourned this meeting to Auaust 8. 2005, at 9:00 a.m. in the Main Conference Room, City Hall,43200 Business Park Drive, Temecula, California 92590. Chairman Albert Blair Director of Planning Ubnoske . . R:/OldT ownlLRB/Minutes/071105 3 . . ITEM #2 . . . . STAFF REPORT - PLANNING ," CITY OF TEMECULA OLD TOWN LOCAL REVIEW BOARD August 8, 2005 PLANNING APPLICATION NO. PA05-0148 Prepared by: Harmony Bales, Assistant Planner APPLICATION INFORMATION APPLICANT: Mr. Carlos Palma Temecula House of Wine 28522 Old Town Front Street Temecula, CA 92590 PROPOSAL: An Administrative Development Plan to construct a new outdoor wine garden to be located in the lot to the north of the Palomar Hotel at the corner of Old Town Front Street and Fifth Street. LOCATION: 28522 Old Town Front Street in the City of Temecula, County of Riverside, State of California EXISTING ZONING: Tourist Retail Core (TRC) SURROUNDING ZONING: North: Tourist Retail Core (TRC) South: Tourist Retail Core (TRC) . East: Tourist Retail Core (TRC) West: Tourist Retail Core (TRC) GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Community Commercial (CC) EXISTING LAND USE: Commercial SURROUNDING LAND USES: North: The Barn South: Country Cottage East:. Vacant West: Antiques/Mad Madeline's Grill PROJECT DESCRIPTION Planning Application No. PA05-0148, submitted by Mr. Carlos Palma of the Temecula House of Wine, consists of an improvement to an existing garden for wine tasting to the north of the Palomar Hotel located at 28522 Old Town Front Street within the Tourist Retail Core (TRC) District of the Old Town Temecula Specific Plan. Wine tasting is a permitted use in the Tourist Retail Core of the Old Town Specific Plan. G:\Planning\2005\P A05-0I48 Temecula House of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report.doc I ANALYSIS . The applicant proposes to replace the existing wood fence facing Old Town Front Street (west elevation) with decorative wrought iron supported by a two-foot high stone base. The current City information sign would be moved to the south closer to the existing building. To the south, the applicant is proposing a three foot high wrought iron fence with a wood trellis facing the Palomar Hotel, and to the north and east the applicant proposes a three foot high solid cedar fence on top of a two-foot high stone base. The maximum height of the fence will be five feet. According to Section IV-27 of the Old Town Specific Plan, wrought iron fencing and decorative wrought iron gates can be used to accentuate a fence, wall, or building. According to the Old Town Specific Plan, all fencing and wall materials utilized within the commercial districts of the Old Town Specific Plan shall be compatible with the architectural theme of the building. The fayade for the existing building carries on the Old Town theme of an old western style, specifically the Spanish Colonial/Mission Style. The proposed irnprovements will enhance this style by providing additional materials, such as wrought iron and stone to the garden area for additional architectural interest and variety. The proposed fence will be consistent with the height and building materials of the Old Town Specific Plan Design Guidelines. In the interior of the garden, the applicant is proposing a pathway of interlocking pavers in Brown Stone blended with Terra Cotta Brown Pavers. Decorative Santa Fe gravel will be spread between the pathways and landscaping. The applicant proposes eleven Canterbury Dining Style tables with ,chairs situated around the garden. On the north side of the garden, the applicant proposes a fireplace flanked by a water feature on both sides. At the rear of the property, a gazebo with a clay tile roof is proposed as a wine tasting area. The applicant proposes to keep the existing elm trees on the property and add additional patio trees and plants. . To the south of the garden, a trellis is proposed that will be planted with grape vines and evergreen vines to help soften the appearance of the trellis in accordance with Section IV-28 of the Old Town Specific Plan. . RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Old Town Local Review Board review, provide comments and recommend approval of the proposed wine garden improvement for the existing building. ATTACHMENTS 1. Site Plan - Blue Page 3 2. Landscape Plan - Blue Page 4 3. Fence Plan - Blue Page 5 4. Decorative Details - Blue Page 6 . G:\Planning\2005\PA05-0148 Temecula House of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report.doc 2 . . . ATTACHMENT NO.1 SITE PLAN G:\Planning\2005\PA05-0148 Tcrnecula House of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report.doc 3 . ~ J ., t f . I t. . ti1 <~ ~ 1t ~- / I .~ Ii ~~ " '<\_~~_.b l:;:{ ;13"j-l-.> -+"G'1!.::l ...--- 1: ~ J " --1.'" '1~ , ,Y/w- ~ i b ' .. I . ", 6- <:\" :!: b I'. V "Q "Q "Q "Q "<J "<J , 5": ~t::l, - - "-\\,. " 'y .Il' : n I 1-.--'\ </' }-.. j' ~_._. -v v 7 V ~ ~I~ II y~-~ <>.~:) f 1 \I 9C~ ^~ -f . . . ATTACHMENT NO.2 LANDSCAPE PLAN G:\Planning\2005\P AOS..Q148 Temecula House of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report.doc 4 . j 1 j <-, S" ..~ v "> " I T""-' .-,.,..,.,. }<?_Vf~~ l;."H"J~.f. I::>/r O:>Z'-5>'1 -tl .<" ~ ~- ~ ~ ; , ,oS'!; e ,\1 '" =:t!l.!foJ 1 -:- s: ,\: I -'- If I r=L" ( . '\ 1 . , -' ~ \ D,4:~b ~7 ,.{l ('J -~---:' \ .........(; ~ -t Q r- ~ " l>.:.o ~V'C\ j.o~,fI~ '---' -f.~ .>.>- -~ ) 'J ..g ~~). 1/'-8\..- 0:S.'9U I ~ --< (jl _I IV OJ 6 r:lt) " 0 ~ J) ,. - - '. i r --..:' ""', " ~?:~ .~. l.; t.,j '" ," . r 1] ~ ~ ,':'. l,O.l!' o - c -- :';:.p:;: :g ~ <, uJ U 4_ -J ")( 'b~ *' , ~]:2 . ~. '7"H 'D '\ 'H I O"O..........j;: \""1; ~ 0 J U o I' ~,- v:' '9 ~ , 'W......-::; .0 ;..SC:" ') UtJ~ ~ .~ -;;:;- ..z ... . --;\" 1 ~ p .....-+ .: 0 \. -E ~ 1~, ~~ 1" .~ ~ -~ S'f ~ 1- , - >1 ...+-. 'B ~ _A ~ a :2 ? ~ ~ ~~ oJ " . - " " J-J ~ I ~ ~'~ 11 ~~' <::J ~'/ <J \';'" .~...' <IF? l;l) <l <l <l <l <l <l <l <l <l \7 <:'. t> \:> <Q t>' <l <J <J .;; Ci ~o,,!> 'U _ -::: -0 - . . ~ ,.:. t:,.3 ti. \...{) -v <;} " v v ,<;J j " < -;-., - .) 3 ~ ~ ~ 'C ~ , ~ ~ o - S ~ -:s ~ tI 5 r .7 '1 " I:>' V> ~r, Y :s"o.- ~ (:) ..!:1 p.... $ 0 v1 [.3 ~ ~ J u'cld. -;; ". .::, o is . --0 :;: ~ ~ i ~ (j..1 ,I' ).~ '3 ::t ~,~ __ v_~ ~ p.. e.- .....!: - ~g~ ~j5 \!j..!]t ::-:::'<f ~ Vl I',~ .:J7',J 'V .<E OC ? ,-:!..J'~ .~ '2 .., "'IV E ,. j \S ~ .,....., ..... ~-1 -J~'- t ~~ ,?" j l!J ..~~C3 :-~ .",..~1('5 ~ . <>~ " ( 1- ') >>.:;) v , '7" . -5 -'- ,.,t <.01': . . . ATTACHMENT NO.3 FENCE PLAN G:\Planning\2005\PA05-0148 Tcmccula I-louse of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB StaffReport.doc 5 .' ..' i I I I J..__ .h L.--- . ""7..........,".- ~ j ---+:- ::::s i I ! 0- c ,; I 'I I.::J J I -r-~ o,z. O-'Z P i " I;, I " , , " 'i i , j . I 1/ ~ I \l:I it:} I II.>> I~ I \ \f T {~ I lR l=r{. , :\1 '''"-- -r 4n: t) -Wi i II :x ! ~\'.... '''''-''< f""- r.' :, .t. 'f"\',)1 ), ; .,....."'.,. 0' >1- "\ ~A~>"., \,.'...'r-,~,:..,.': , .....:. >li<If '~."..', "-.- i~."~"''''''~''''~ / ,,~? f . tf/ " - \'-"\ ---.--- l' . '-- ,,; \ t.;;::1"' "....0 .....:L....:..);:.)~.. :1./')' ~r ...t . t~r ~ . it'! I ".j~, I-i' ", . ...r..-..j-.-,., . \ ~\ \ A rr ',ll Ji -}!j. ill! ~I ! .~':~" A ~ 11. .tL ~ " A ~ ~ 'f_~ ">-- 1 ! 1: ..u ~,' -:s:-,.." 4: J. II ~ "Y' :I · '-r." \ T ~ .,' ,),1. ;r j J 1 ' , ,'~? -::t ')- ...--,\_ · .r-4' j r. fi --r-- L ~"~ ~ at~ I I J-Y=- I I I 1 ~ & . J -~~-~- '. ~ i ' ,~- oj I' ---=-.~' 'rlr--r \l'l ti. _~-- 11:1 ~ 1~ } i ~-\- .- -'. ~ --;:i ~ -l 1 ~ . .=-= -:,- tl ~ / j~ . ~ \'~ ( , ~~ ~ .- h-~ ~,! ~ 3 & \..... j ~ ~ <l i j ~ \ H~ I , , . i (/ '1: J 'I, -;.} . )~if " )rf/ ,/( ,~ . -. \ f" " '...~' 1\ f\ t..,'" \ t4... , ::1" ~ t> c pi ;t.: ~ " ---'- ,~_._- . L! . {} { } 1.\ ...J ~ . ,\ . /'{'""' I /1 (, \ \~~- """,/" 11 ,~.;.... . . ,,~t.. >''''oj''!' - -'<' ......- .~ ~ :: tl-~ ci+ , l--\- ",1., ! ~ \f3 ~t I 't': { \- ii \, . 1 A , . 1-'" l\1" ,,1 -:-; , " -1 , Jst , \ , \ , Ql _. i , (I >t ~I I , ~ N 4 . . :~~' j . ,;', . ,." ~ . -.... . .,........ l -~ --..... '.. . . ') ~.:.J. . . . ATTACHMENT NO.4 DECORATIVE DETAILS G:\Planning\2005\PAOS-0148 Temecula House of Wine Facade Improvement-ADP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report.doc 6 . . Nt... · DtJRANGO Mountain Ledge . . pe.~-t.~ ~\1Et... - ""$4 ~ ~~A1J.... . ReD BLOCK &BRICK RCP BLOCK & BRICK, INC. ~. INTERLOCKING PAVERS ..... '-;' 5, . ,_,',"~!:Yi,if: -,"'\ji_';;"Ji;',,:0.__ Full.-Unrt~~, ':';-(t,"'''''',-(l;_, '~4: xS. '.2. .1 7,' piece$ .' , ,~\~ ;; Colors: . ': " ~ ":',', : ,,'",_,' -;'>'1 Bro~n Stone,(jray',:.~ .,"' Terra Cotta Brownl'Cof variation is inhiire"ii,jl}j cor/crete prodiJd ., ~: " ':'--}:--)~~11~i A numberofprQd~tis .~' manufactured ily;RCP } '~'., . "'.' .-.>; "','-'.;::__ "<-;'_':f">""_" r BloCk & Brick-contain' recy~iedco~te~i;jr:' .. ....., CBULA VISTA 15 N. Fourth A~. Chula VIsta. CA (619)-474~1516 . SANTEE . 8755 Magnolia SBnttt. CA 1_619}-448-2240 SERVING SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SINCE 1947 wWlp.rcpblock.com LEMON GROVE ESCONDIDO 8246 Broadway, l070W. MisslonAve. Inrion Grove. CA Escondldo. CA 1619H60-9101 . 1760).480-9696 MllRRIETA 25725 JeffeTSOll Ave. MWTieta, CA t909}...677-1489 ENCINlTAS 577 N. Vulcan Ave. F;nctnItas.CA (7601-753-1164 Canterbury Dining, Mallin Patio Furniture, outdoor patio furniture, covers, wicker alumin...\ Page 1 of 3 " MaHin Canterbury Dining t patio covers I patio umbrellas I wicker patio furniture I aluminum patio furniture .}:~" tilf Home lB Who We Are Frame Finishes & Fabrics Call Toll Free Or Email 1-877-930-7070 For All Price Quotes And Information! o Online Store Canterbury Dining Hl Brands Hl Patio Products EI Bistro Collection o Outdoor Barstoof Sets o Optional Table Tops EI Patio Umbrellas/Bases o Umbrellas & Awnings [!] Frame Finishes & Fabrics [J Protective Covers [J Replacement Cushions o Opt. Furniture Fabrics o Tea Carts EJ Accessories o Shipping Policy o Links o Contact/Price Quote (}lroauct pamify httn'//-n.T\7JUJ n~tlnfJ1rnlhlrp.fnrnl1trlnnr~ I"nn'l/m~ ,..~ntPThl1n,_rl;n;n('J html "111/'l1l1l" . . .