Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout051109 OTLRB AgendaIn compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please contact the office of the City Clerk (951) 694-6444. Notification 48 hours prior to a meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to that meeting 128 CFR 35.102.35.104 ADA Title III AGENDA OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD MAIN CONFERENCE ROOM 43200 BUSINESS PARK DRIVE May 11, 2009 - 9:00 a.m. CALL TO ORDER Roll Call: Board Members: Blair, Eden, Wafts and Chairman Moore PUBLIC COMMENTS A total of 15 minutes is provided so members of the public may address the Board on items that are listed on the Agenda. Speakers are limited to three (3) minutes each. If you desire to speak to the Board about an item not on the Agenda, a green "Request to Speak" form should be filled out and filed with the Board Secretary. When you are called to speak, please come forward and state your name for the record. For all other agenda items a "Request to Speak" form must be filed with the Board Secretary pr for to the Board addressing that item. There is a three (3) minute time limit for individual speakers. NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC All matter listed under Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and all will be enacted by one roll call vote. There will be no discussion of these items unless members of the Local Review Board request specific items to be removed from the Consent Calendar for separate action. CONSENT CALENDAR Minutes RECOMMENDATION 1.1 Approve the Minutes of April 13, 2009 R:\Old Town\Agendas\2009\05-11-09 Agenda.doc BOARD BUSINESS 2 Planning Application Nos. PA09-0101 and PA07-0302, a Conditional Use Permit located at 28673 Puiol Street Applicant: Otto and Nancy Baron 28681 Pujol Street Temecula, CA 92590 Staff: Cheryl Kitzerow/Matt Peters BOARD MEMBERS REPORT CITY PLANNER REPORT SPECIAL EVENTS REPORT May Special Events ADJOURNMENT Next regular meeting: Monday, June 8, 2009, 9:00 a.m., Main Conference Room, City Hall, 43200 Business Park Drive, Temecula, CA 92590 The agenda packet (including staff reports) will be available for viewing at City Hall's Planning Department Public Counter located at 43200 Business Park Drive and at the Temecula Library located at 30600 Pauba Road during normal business hours. The packet will be available for viewing the Wednesday before the Old Town Local Review Board meeting after 4:00 p.m. You may also access the packet the Thursday before the meeting after 4:00 p.m. on the City's website at www.rityoftemecula.org. R:\Old Town\Agendas\2009\05-11-09 Agenda.doc ITEM #1 ACTION MINUTES OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD MAIN CONFERENCE ROOM 43200 BUSINESS PARK DRIVE April 13, 2009 - 9:00 a.m. **kk*#tk* CALL TO ORDER Roll Call: Board Members: Blair, Eden, Wafts and Chairman Moore Absent: Moore CONSENT CALENDAR Minutes RECOMMENDATION 1.1 Approve the Minutes of December 8, 2008 APPROVED 3-0 MOORE ABSENT, MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER WATTS, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER EDEN; VOICE VOTE REFLECTED UNANIMOUS APPROVAL 1.2 Approve the Minutes of February 25, 2009 APPROVED 3-0 MOORE ABSENT, MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER WATTS, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER EDEN; VOICE VOTE REFLECTED UNANIMOUS APPROVAL BOARD BUSINESS Elect Chair and Vice Chair (NO ACTION TAKEN) 2.1 Planning Application Nos. PA08-0288 Minor Modification for a fagade improvement APPROVED 3-0 MOORE ABSENT, MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER EDEN, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER WATTS; VOICE VOTE REFLECTED UNANIMOUS APPROVAL, PA09-0012 Sign Program APPROVED 3-0 MOORE ABSENT, MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER WATTS, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER EDEN; VOICE VOTE REFLECTED UNANIMOUS APPROVAL, and PA09-0045 Certificate of Historic Appropriateness APPROVED 3-0 MOORE ABSENT, MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER EDEN, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER WATTS; VOICE VOTE REFLECTED UNANIMOUS APPROVAL for the Emporium commercial complex, located at 42050 Main Street Applicant: Matthew Fagan Consulting Services 42011 Avenida Vista Ladera Temecula, CA 92591 Staff: Dana Schuma R:\Old Town\Minutes\2009\041309.doc BOARD MEMBERS REPORT CITY PLANNER REPORT Code Enforcement Actions in Old Town SPECIAL EVENTS REPORT Special Events scheduled for April and May ADJOURNMENT Next regular meeting: Monday, May 11, 2009, 9:00 a.m., Main Conference Room, City Hall, 43200 Business Park Drive, Temecula, CA 92590 Albert Blair Vice Chairman Patrick Richardson City Planner R:\Old Town\Minutes\2009\041309.doc ITEM #2 STAFF REPORT- PLANNING CITY OF TEMECULA OLD TOWN LOCAL REVIEW BOARD May 11, 2009 PLANNING APPLICATION NOS. PA09-0101 and PA07-0303 Prepared by: Cheryl Kitzerow and Matt Peters, Associate Planners APPLICATION INFORMATION: APPLICANT: Otto and Nancy Baron 28681 Pujol Street Temecula, CA 92590 PROPOSAL: A Conditional Use Permit (PA09-0101) and Certificate of Historic Appropriateness (PA07-0303) to allow the operation of a for-profit museum with associated museum gift shop within the historic Arviso House located on 0.48 acres at 28673 Pujol Street Street within the Old Town Specific Plan area (Arviso House was recently relocated from 41915 Fourth Street). The project includes the existing 1,023 square foot historic Arviso House and proposes to add a screened porch, attached 702-square foot storage room, and a 206-square foot hospitality cabin and restrooms. LOCATION: Generally located on the west side of Pujol Street, approximately 200 feet south of Main Street, at 28673 Pujol Street EXISTING ZONING: Old Town Specific Plan: Medium Density Residential (MDR) SURROUNDING ZONING: North Medium Density Residential (MDR) South: Medium Density Residential (MDR) East: High Density Residential (HDR) West: Specific Plan 8; Industrial Park (IP) GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential (M) EXISTING LAND USE: The Historic Arviso House has been relocated to the proposed site from 41915 Fourth Street (currently on temporary riser blocks). The property was otherwise vacant except for a 70+ year-old shed previously known to be a blacksmith shop. SURROUNDING LAND USES: North: Residential (single family house) South: Residential (Mr. and Mrs. Baron's personal residence) East: Apartment complex West: Vacant/hillside GAPLANNBQG\2009NA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUP\Planning\OTLRB Staff ReportPA09-0101 doc 1 BACKGROUND/PROJECT DESCRIPTION The Historic Arviso House was originally constructed in 1920 by Ventura Arviso as a wood framed residence for his family who were members of the Pechanga Indian Band. Ventura Arviso worked for the Vail Cattle Ranch and together with his wife raised at least four children at this house. The residence stayed within the family until it was purchased in 1996 by the current owner/applicant, Otto and Nancy Baron. Since then, the Barons have remodeled the structure to bring the building into compliance with contemporary building codes in order to allow public access for a retail shop. The applicant utilized the Arviso House as an antique boutique and period mercantile shop called "Kreigers General Mercantile" from approximately 1999 until May 2007 at the northwest corner of Mercedes and Fourth Street. On May 7, 2007, the Arviso House was moved to its current location at 28673 Pujol Street, where it remains on temporary riser blocks until approval of this project. The applicants propose a western themed for-profit museum, "Temecula's Heritage Ranch," at this location. On October 30, 2007, the applicant submitted an application for a Conditional Use Permit and Certificate of Historic Appropriateness for the "Temecula's Heritage Ranch." Pursuant to Section III.C (Land Use Regulations) of the Old Town Specific Plan, a for-profit museum is allowable upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit. In addition, a Certificate of Historic Appropriateness application was required pursuant to Section V (Finding of Historic Appropriateness) of the Old Town Specific Plan for exterior renovations to a historic structure. Proposed renovations to the Arviso House included a new color palette, the addition of a screened porch, a basement and a hospitality cabin. On November 29, 2007, a Department Review Committee meeting was held at City Hall with the applicant; and a comment letter was sent outlining staffs requested revisions to the site plan. Additionally, staff and the applicant had several over-the-counter meetings and telephone conferences to move the project forward through the entitlement process. On February 1, 2008, the applicant re-submitted all plans and staff determined the project was ready to be heard by the Old Town Local Review Board. On March 10, 2008, the Old Town Local Review Board recommended approval of PA07-0302, a Conditional Use Permit for the operation of a for-profit museum (Temecula's Heritage Ranch) and PA07-0303, Certificate of Historical Appropriateness to permit the proposed modifications to the historic Arviso House. On April 3, 2008, both PA07-0302 and PA07-0303 were approved at a Director's Hearing. On March 16, 2009, Otto and Nancy Baron submitted a new Conditional Use Permit application, which contains revisions to the site plan resulting from the applicant's desire to not set the historic building on a basement. Rather, the applicants are proposing to set the building on a slab foundation and add a storage room to the back of the building. In effect, the applicants are proposing to rescind the approval of PA07-0302, Conditional Use Permit and replace with PA09- 0101. In addition, PA07-0303, Certificate of Historical Appropriateness will be amended to reflect the proposed architectural changes. ANALYSIS Site Plan A site plan has been submitted with the Conditional Use Permit application to plot the proposed location of the Arviso House, porch, hospitality cabin and restrooms, parking, driveway, landscaping and accessibility pathways. GAPLANNEW2009TA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUPV'lanning\OTLRB Staff Report PA09-0101.doc 2 The site plan meets the minimum requirements of the development standards for Medium Density Residential (MDR) within the Old Town Specific Plan. Its building lot coverage of 11 percent is well below the maximum permitted lot coverage of 35 percent. In addition, the landscaping/open space coverage exceeds the minimum 25 percent for MDR zoning district. All uses within the MDR zoning district require on-site parking consistent with the Temecula Municipal Code and the project meets the required four spaces based upon 1,126 square feet of museum display (museum and hospitality cabin). An existing legally nonconforming shed that is approximately 70 years old will remain onsite (not for public use). Though the shed is deteriorating, the applicants have agreed, and the project will be conditioned to ensure the shed is restored to maintain an orderly appearance. Architecture The existing Arviso House architecture will remain in tact; however, the applicant is proposing an attached screened porch along the southern side towards the rear of the structure. The screened porch will incorporate elements of the main structure, including a matching concrete tile roof (shake style) and complimentary board and baton hardi-plank wood siding along the base. Staff has determined that a porch addition is historically appropriate since the Arviso House previously had a screened porch that was dismantled in the 1990s due to unsafe conditions. A proposal for a 206-square foot "hospitality cabin" (intended for additional museum display) is also planned along the southern side of the Arviso House, directly in front of the proposed screened porch essentially blocking the porch from public view. The hospitality cabin will incorporate design elements of the main structure consistent with western frontier style architecture including a covered front porch with wood braced columns, complementary board and baton wood siding (using hardi-plank for durability) and the same shake-like roofing materials as used on the Arviso House and proposed screened porch. A covered parking canopy with matching roof tiles and wooden columns will extend along the south side of the Hospitality Cabin primarily to display an antique car owned by the applicant. The Old Town Specific Plan, Section IV, indicates that accessory buildings located in residential districts shall incorporate architectural treatments from the main building including siding, surface materials, trim, paint colors and roof materials. Originally, as part of the approval of PA07-0302, the applicant proposed two different color schemes from the Sherwin Williams Preservation Palette to distinguish between the Hospitality Cabin and the Historic Arviso House. Staff recommended that the applicant select either one of the two color schemes to meet the Old Town Specific Plan and to ensure consistency and continuity of the proposed Heritage Ranch. Consistent with the original approval, the main body color of the buildings will be painted Downing Stone (gray) with trim painted Downing Sand and Accents painted Rookwood Dark Brown. Landscaping All pavement proposed for the driveway, parking area and pedestrian pathways will be decorative beige colored concrete. The existing white split rail fencing will line half of the property north of the parking lot connecting with side fencing. The site plan calls out landscaping along the front perimeter of the property and the project has been conditioned to provide additionally enhanced drought-resistant landscaping consistent with the landscape guidelines of the Old Town Specific Plan to ensure an appealing front yard. G:\PLANNING\2009\PA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report PA09-0101.doc 3 Signage Existing The building signage on the Arviso House was previously reviewed and approved by the Old Town Local Review Board on May 9, 2005 allowing "Dry Goods" and "Variety Store" as depicted on the current plans. The "Kreigers General Mercantile" sign is existing. No additional building signage is being proposed. Proposed Pursuant to Old Town Specific Plan Section III.G.1, signage proposed within the Medium Density Residential Districts shall comply with Development Code Section 17.28.110 (Signs for Institutional and other Permitted Uses in Residential Districts). One freestanding business sign is permissible, no greater than four feet tall. The applicant is proposing an L-shaped sign post capped with a cattle skull. No dimensions have been indicated, therefore, the proposed projecting monument sign is allowable at a maximum four feet in height; and will be conditioned to be fabricated from sandblasted or carved wood. Fonts and colors will be reviewed under a separate permit consistent with Old Town sign design standards. Staff expressed concern regarding the cattle skull and how it fits in with the surrounding residential neighborhood. Therefore, staff is seeking input from the Old Town Local Review Board regarding the cattle skull. RECOMMENDATION Staff requests that the Old Town Local Review Board provide comments, and a recommendation for approval, regarding the Conditional Use Permit and Certificate of Historic Appropriateness. ATTACHMENTS Plan Reductions - Blue Page 5 2. Statement of Operations and Statement of Justification - Blue Page 6 GAPLANNING\2009TA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUP\P1anning\0TLR13 Staff Report PA09-0101.doc 4 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 PLAN REDUCTIONS GAPLANNING\2009\PA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report PA09-0101.doc 5 v~~~sa ~ia 19RSOS 8961 ` § R n" p ~~en fwml w aidlu u99a asym M~NVVa 3N V= 1 31 9 y ,a a >m 31 4 - @ 1 g ~ 3 3 ~ ~ $ t t s a H 7 7 3 I z 3 $ $ a rata l`7: I ` ~C~ 9f R i gg6 `'y~4 ky 7r~/~ ~ jcctee ie 1 S a~i J~ eq !`8dP € E~g pp qn R iS _ ¢H Rig a E WIN ~ d dd g ~H 6d qQS@gQgO¢lt dga 6 1 $l$ipy 7,p fUll 3 I d§5~FF~~~~~36~~ ~ ` - ~ ?3~ sd 8a$ ~ ! E 3 ~ ± 96€ ~ Yt~ 4- ~ , t 1 " IS _ r cna .1 111111, ~ 1 1 1 ` 1 1. , r', 1111, 111 ~ 1\ 1\ 1\ 1 : , It 1111111111 1\ I i'~ ~ r~il`I-~~1\`I ~liil'll ii 11 \`1I~I f r r ?j IIa 1 1, 11111 Po i ~~~'~~ry'-~r ~ I~ I! I i I I i 11 vvaS i ~rr ~ ~ X111, 11111 ,II ~ % ~ a' ~ 1 11 4°Il~$~r r r ~ rl\ 1j _ - 1111111 \ i r l a o illll r a ~ J' a} a 1 L Its s8 ryL;~L: ,~.s I , dl\ r 1a 1 a e r w i IO r 1 v ~6~sap ~a~ wwv3vu~ ~,o„ i n roec w FpNtlil 39tlJR13HM fg3 YV3 1 r, 01- Ali I a fig, ~ s r 4 . tl a t • a e d `J1 f vxunwocsrmuw vi ~ sa ~i a en ~ l91¢~90S f1%I t~ aF 1 } 11 HONYU 39YlRl3H rttp3M i i _ w ova 3VvuaN Vim mm Y 2 28 F~~ iY~ { II ':1'111 I ~ gp~ { IIII I'.illll IIII4 ~I111 IIi' 1'gll z S~ I I g- •8 ® ~gcgy g ~ I ~lllil' j~ F ~qi Iii U IJ,I a € I II'1 I II iI 1 Ii li.l'n 1,.I, I !I'ii1 i1ih: li a I,.-,;i l l i l Ilil F I I R I. "III ~ ~ I'''I II 11li,,l ill,l: it 'II'I Ij III I ail ii 1 II III E € iI~111 I, 6 III I'll p i~i I' II11 ;i11 li o 11. , i 1 II 1 qc;~ - i 111. Ili .Ij ii III 1,' Z P F 69i llil Iii 'Z E l; 1111.1 OF F i illll 'I j I = Iplill 'I ~ I111:,1~~'I! ~ ~ W I Ili = ,ill III i W 1 o ¢ 1 a k li Iii! L . ~ I' I'~ llii 1111 W r, 1; li 'L wxunwmarmcu v~~~sap ~ia~~bn NYMBOaM _ OGSd6Lv"roweL 1t,0,tliawa V 4 • mm C 5: ^ax ° a m HJN R 39VIR13H VL1g3W3L 3 a i3S 1 e f r e E 3~ e s b L c - a p I 3 m w W 3 3 a F~ t, I $F1Y ~f{( I t ` FI~ f$ Ifra {f[g ajlf,~j pf~i 9 Lflf" 1aa~ ~ C g fi~rF•3 ! ~ Fap r $ = z i EigSj i}j {Bi~f y~ t°, s€x Ff ~ ~3 f: ! e~ea~ l l{t{{~lapa 65 g i i PStg § PE!'x6 t ~ F S s `C ~f •5 ¢EF tF L ~t FFgI~e Faj~ f ;(z~ IS :tr~a 9 Fsfa@{ ss{~aF : j? ~j~.g 1afE ~ $ r8$$ig~ ~;€FLisi, ~is=~ artaf P +EE F~a:~ ,€f~ L - F i}•r~,~= Off fF~ 1~a F,~ ~ff.€~ ~FfgF='FF'-~~ ~ S:'F~: isi7 e¢¢= ~x= Ig3 ~ .r; In N11, ,.F 3 i rffLx fs ±r; [aP;i a. a aas s a i,$a f~ftfas it r N ¢ F~ p=r p~~ ~d L ~'3 ~ a q pE 8 C o m F: g ~ FS s4c ~ Fe~ Fg ~ r @ a~ L to t b rs Q ~a ¢ L L A~ fyS~ L~~1 r&& N a ~b p2 ~ O ~ Q a a ~ ~ ¢ a uF F §F A ! m - -f--~-~--~ F~4t1y P~ : 1• 2 E Y:,d O 1~~~8 c • pa~ ~ t~ _ A~ da 3L M1b 1 a p F ~ 'x ~I. 6 ® Y i ~ ~ ~C Y tl e Y g y ggi q 6 I Y lot 91 INN B 3q§ g !g. paQ i~ giggj@ ¢y~~ Mill ~ 111111 .S1 11, § ppp e~ 9~ E ~ 2 g~@ E 8p~2 q9 p~ 8 ga 3~~ ~6 a ~ i ~P!'4 ayy R~ ~p € ~ia b ~p e~~ ES ~ 3g a~l ~ ~ 6 ®59 eeeeiviveviC veevv~$ I I e YYY i9 gg E E @@ [ @tl S :l aQ 6$ 3 @s$ii Sae o e y gy 3¢ fill e~gtE€ts`eei3~is0~ I i ■~p 3i ~ eQ C~ Y ~b Y g~ v ~ Y Y ~ 6§`4 14 4 ~ ~ ! n I ~ 6 E C7 Q J U W i F 0 U aa~~ i pg . 8 a 4 1 y~ 3 N 8 R - - u 8 z `a Y 'Hole 13341 ~of nd ®®g yyI] E it ] $~i~ - i@ 8 33 d r u / 'N 96 MJ S - p IOC Y c2 ht`>-r+r'^-ice.. a{ Nk, k'lm Its Z0~ ~ --gzo t- B r----ON I- ZZ! / i'- i OCOIJ - _-_WoI--------_ Hl 0 111 1 nlQllllll 1111 Iul iIIITIIIITI ITIIIrIIllr~lllrllllr IIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII! 11111!!1 11IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII~IIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII ~IIIIIIIIII1111111i IIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII !IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII!Illllfi IIIlilllllll (IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIII!IIIIII!I 1!11!!1 4! ltlwD1U1 II n IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIiI (IIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIfIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIfIIll JD1111111111p~11 fll!W IIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII IIIIIII 1111111111!IIIIIillllllll flllllll Illlllllfllll II I~ 111!111 Ill 1111111 IIIIIIIIII IN I I I III 11111111111 111 1 1! Will IIIIII111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII 111 I1 11111111 IIIIIllllru IIII 111111/11 111!1111111 11 11 !1 1111111 HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII III 111111 111111111!IIttNNtlffi Will l IIIIIIIIIIIIII 1111111! IIIIIIIIIIIIfIIlllllllll IIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIII ! IIIIIIIII o Illllllllli! II 11!I~I VIIIIIIII !(IIIIIIIIIII I Ililllll ~ ~ IIIIIIIIII! IIIHill IIIIIII IIIIIIIIIII II Ilf IIIIIIIII w IIIIIIIII IIII I II II IIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII ti I I II I IIIIIIIIII III IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIillll IIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII I I I I I l l IIII I I I I I I I I! I I I I I I I I I I I I I I! I I I I I !III I IIIIIIIIII IIII III I !!111111 (IIIIIII! (IIIIIIIIIII I111!IIII IIIIIIIIII IIII 111 l 111!111 IIIIIIIIII iiiiii111 IIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII 111111 IIIIIIIIII 1111111111' 111111 lllfllll llll ll 111 IIIIIIIII HIM Il11, IIIIIIII III III IIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIII il11111111LL11-_ l IIIIIIIIII IIII II IIIIIIIII ¢ , I!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIiI!G1111111111 !IIIIIIIIII 1 Illll!1!Ilo i IIIIIIIIII!!I!I!1IIIH 1111IIIIIII IIIII!I!IIIIIIIII I!111111111.11~i!IIII!I!I!IIIIIIIIIIII111111111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIII III,IIIIIII!III!11N!Illllfjillljl!Iljlll!III11!IIIj IIIIIIIIIIIIIIlllhlWIlu11!Ifll s s a IIIIIIIIIIIIIII!1! iidlidililfl1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 11111 ! I I! I I I! I I I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIII! IIIIIlill11!I!II e a !IIIIIIIIIIIIIII I IIII II I IIIII I I I 3:f i 91 111111111111111'lllll!IIII!IIII!II €i9-'f~~ Ilill!IIIIIIIII !IIIIil111!Ilii!II ee®~~®® IIIIIIIIIIIIII 111111!IIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIII!II!Ill IHIiIIIIIIIHIIIIII IIIIIII!IIIII IIIII!IIIIIIII!I!il !IIIIIIIIIII! I!Illllllllif IIIIIII Ililllllllll IIIIIIIII':ilIll!I!IIII Illll!IIIII I I IIIIIIIII I I!II11111 IIIIIIIII !IIIIIIIIIIiiiiiiIII!II IIIII!I!II':I!II!I!II!IIlIIf1!III!II II!II!IIIIIlIIIII!111IIIIIL'IIIIIII 111111111:, lllllllllllll!11!IIIIII II!11111111111!IIII!IIIIIII!II1111~~ - IIIIIIIIII~L'1111111i1111!I!!IIIIII $@~ ~q ~ I ~ IIIIII1111111II!II!I!11I!Ili11!I IDllW1tIWll!1LIp I IIIIJ j iLlllll II!IIIIIIIIII!III!IIIIIII ' ~ ins ~ I !I!II!ICIIIII!IIIIII!11111ilIIlll HIN 5h I!ll~ill!IIIII!II!II!IIIiI1!II 11!111 !IIIIIII!IIIIII!IllIfIIIIIII !Ill ,iilli'll!I!IIIIi111p!IIIII ~ a:,€ a11~. i1111!!IIIIII!Ilf!II!1I1111I1! ~~11a ~;res'-a_ Nllnl!fiuuuu11u!iululliiu ~ ;a a~rg~~€ 15M Noll x~z 9d p~ ioio 000 i e®o s~ 0 s a: a J J (J w a w 0 U a 'a$ 3 ?a :r 4 a z b its II 9Y S t ~'s ® • e ®!3 s f il l a b F qq ?~'~11 ~ ~ @6 . l~~~ lE C6 z 11 it-III Hill Easais ; ~i33dis iornd ~a - a n, Ix is M O O I N [O - O i N az / a- a ~ ~ m U W W ~ li O , OZOI--= - a g SZO e Fr e G[ I' - -14 II p IL / i d' C7 k 4 4 tl a f 0 I ~tl ~ a I ~ v i plot 9 6 e Ixszo CO., yF~yq~q .Y qp qq 1. 9C ygy ~3$ ~~~e£D£Ed SM~ py I ~ e48 e~.r+~~ •~4~bLGTST~~ .airy. ~ ~°5 3 `?e ro ;Z0 _ -NOI_ ~l' / -Sf0 t 06926 YJ .C33N 701nd U98Z 1S'IONd EL9HZ HDNtlH HDVJ IHHH S,V MDah3,L in NOWEI ADNVN W 0110 U ~ ~°0-ao~e3e a' Z w a¢ x ~~g$;e.sa:e ~d w Z u . C3 aye sY s, e a o! ~ Q x x a w w 8 3° a t G g i m o o ~ F W 'o o j i W U O_ Q N¢ z O Z 0 0 0 G7 w g gB i J Q ee F a J IN W a a N AA w i@F . 3 , a z s C, New. ra v 1i z ? W y u ¢ 0 W y 9 5$$9S 9 $$fi 9i 3 6a' a a !Z- Q @@ e 9 N 1 W F i N LS !~1 o M 0 N 7 0 N x g:~ &Ft@~~ +tl g 4 4ggi @ a ' yyyy S&y 4 lg9ie ' L ~ tl~~ P l i Yael+g : 1 i IgQig; ! I ie If 1~ ~Epga I ~ ~ B IRON Ig@ g ~JMp6~ E~9t pp Q ggepIg tEt] Ef p@QPil~il gl A i g'lg If I 4 O i@ 1~1 g~i eB!g ;ig@j p~III If °E age 1 ~ 1~4i g a~p ~ ,e~ Oq ea; ,6 pi@,s ~I@ eg.1;yif Bpi p ~ lp9Y i ill ia`'!S'@aFg law9 @ I g@ag le 1991 ij@9a9i~ il9 ig f Y y y oil .1h 7119 I gpi gl Elg .3 IN is ;a if •g@i we e3 ig 49 Et 4' °1'.I U-n qg AA 9ai HM gy~. , We H t9g ; if el .@I a @pg p ! ! ijB119 :i 9!aj gi; g;: ai@ pgaio] H III m ill Va. Ce' I I is€° 16ei iIl i ;g4 gle¢ gg~.l,'=gi j'd vF E @ g ° a If ;g: i ai` 14 ag 1 a 4'I 1, 9e 1 3 z ippa Y 8 l~g~E jii@ g~ g aye ?:9 @Ej; a~l9,= apj ~gp J 9jgY a aslfi 9 gg! @!i @ i': leg +@°gg'~g!@ ~gl aeg e ag,g g`Fig li9 a 9 i a lap §Sa alid' sla:@p ig• §3A ~II! ~.3eg, jgsii Igl a .®@e 119 C,:i ill..l !Is IN ~ pge~ ~g ig a . i's3 @ . Gi! .Yi4 g I! i'- `lip ~E,1 g p .~S l,.9 ea a I' flii 'j 1 ; ;pj ap is Q aah 91 ! a g ! p_IB p @ g!s glg, s; gg p . : ipggi ; E @ii li6@i I y~ 11g gel z e<•° t ga a IY@S@ a a @I~. ga ig j a i age 11! If If eg I ' 3gi@g3 @ e ill' '~~Si ',g B [ ay pal ~•Ye 9 tap gS 1 4 1 p1 19 g e gllg ;51Y9 ! pg SgFqp Ig egg ggj'li °ei g 7 gS~v,a a a if Ig9S NO gg 9 all g;ed gls 1 4 . ia!S,: a is 11 pg 6 a ! a•e S iiii pii'li gg I ~g4;0yg s~ as if MI ~Ba~a i 8t~ Ip Bml ag ~Hgil: e9 it Sila Igl ' i g • ~ e a S a gi g I 1 Q X c EIF!si a '7g !j: @ 'F'°lllee'paa~ 9 `lalg ytz5Fa1l15F a: @3 @l a.a is,s~°ailgiggp dl4j;~a t~l ii ile~ @' ei°`~ 3i 9 g a !e 4'9@ s e gli~ Ep ;I@j1,~9 S -6!I ~ agg:f cY9 @ [a@@i 'e ' 41 IN 9 g;~i ipa~ga ~g 90 ea i~:i e4 Ilp@a;alS~l ,ai@ ali,g~gl~gg99 °SI le @~6ei : S~ , `iil IE gaecjS ! SE't i a ii1 Ij -iia®a 9 eg$~ I jag a+Is~gi ; ~ I~~S p 5 ~S y I.,IL g °i 'gFa~S , v ae Igaaee@:I 4I1° F 5 i gg! Ffilgi g ,lig! jl gl F gE, ie agyg~l l 1 gig1'S g gi as ggllaepeg € e$ e§ 1IE0 gi IS49@I 9 413@I 111°1 g°II 'P J a F I leg e a Y ,.Ga 4 I ea 1 a ! aet i a if g Y., v@@a I• al 1 a 3°~ a Ilj p !la @ p 11 pIP le sa Sal 11 a I @ ta. ra e° la s EI ~ I'll; ° g~ 9Ig~• a @ $ ~ II g 'a Ya a ig s c I S! @ g ,pal @ ! g 1 a ! I e .tai ii 1 1 @ s a S@ ~@p'!S p; jjl~gi p@ gig4i @g ajG F p;: `j; 9s Ig @SE.. II I a I ig a jag''-g Ig F g I i je 4:i'pg it jll S; yI giii@ g' 911: @all g°a I~ 4 gi' s 9 11 II ! g S _I19 X ~g I: li s a .g il~~ga Egg :ip~aa je ,a9't Y' 4gf a '€e Ila4' 1! a ~@ g I; F Y ie ! ; s a a ai a@ 91g a a Lj if gggla °ieaml 3g a~~g :I i pg g 9, , Ii4B i ii € 9I1a g i l. ! @g°pg "~;@ a pl gee Sg ,pg,gl ii g4`eilap ; e.,,4 I a 6 i °1 iilI eae SS g ~gSl i ' g : ~i 1 : ' i~+= aoe~i if g e ii S a @ii4 , a palal @9 i•d , a°' p !P Bag• g Y F if kill a•°9 9~ 9S a @ a p@ I gggeg i Y ga E ii..3 : 9SII 4111 Ilg a ig 1 al.a@ p'j g t ! i'1g s is i, I I !N i~ C t'!!9 Fi+ ~a€ aS a e . g dil- a S ` g ! IN , ,e . gg g gei . a ji 11 I.j pl ; [I i9E~ Wl ii°°i 11 Q I a •4~@ NOW. g gga9 a~ F'Ei taFl 111 ~ ~ I i !€a y s kil l if g . a i g f' g iiFi gglii I'll, 11 . Pig a ~ .~aais soma uvez e w.a ~ o.~ ~.h®IDO®/® HJNtlN H~Jtl.LIllHH S,tl7f1~3113.L s,,, ' $g e ° NO2Id8 AONdN W O.LLO„_„ 3 8 O lit ®a ®6 !3 !x tl gig e i E :g ®a gE ; g ~ ~3' Ag ~E ~y 8~ t ~Y 45~ sE py~b i~ 6: e it gib 4r Ili,. a ? 3 i7 Egg a $E ~ : f' ~ieE s3 adz Egg 3 6 gs AE Y i3 !11 ,111 ihC l J K H U O ~ , U LL_ 1 ~ ¢ ~ j - Z W O Z Z V O o N In N W~ 000 W Q l7 W z a Q N z 2' N ~ Q Q LL N H O Z O O Lij a C] z_ Q cr- LL CK 0 0 J LL 1 ..-e esn -.wa 06926 v0 Y'xOD3 l nm~e~anax dH3N1S 10fnd EL99Z x®~ H~PIVN HxJVMRH &y_MDHNIH,L 99N F_ A3mvN w OYLO 0 i! a g ! ~ iii ! i !s a vi v.a $ ! o{I$ din iye $ gi 4 e!i g ~ d 3 a;g a~s 1 ~P 8 iEi a P1da , ~ i!g !a Fi`s NiP ~~si alle<°si$[3 RNI'mMIN $iild i $e is e gvt € a!a g9g nva S,P yv: a ! ~ ~ i iE i$i e$ ei i~ ix 8x gg~- iiP$ ila•e € O O ! w J Q V v Z Q LL LL O O iz I Y ~ ! ! .i~li d 111 1 di's~~+i1~p 1 t ' i i! Y . 4 e eee Be e t id! = 1!sli i. i;i d6`i i' EH i?;s;dI Yiii,ijii!aSION; ae a ~i ~i ! e4 i ` a i 101, N9L6Y VIWUi31 J33a1S lowo UM HEN" aDVINaH &VICORNal N02jtlfl IONVN w O uo pe j i ii I= Yi a: d M 23 H9 i:iii 'g Hii! Iii 433 d Orms Ali .i ~ m 1 ' dts " i• .I: ^ 0 3 I a d ! i i•' ii it i! , aaaa a j i a •i~; i'i s H ii Ia 6 se 000. 0 a ~ 4 i ill' Ij ~ I~!iiii~i Iiiilliii:ii Isis e Bees sae ~I 1 Ij!i di .!1:1lis ease eee =i=I ! seed d m di i Yi iji ails ejF e e a e e fi 1 'JJJ4 g'e Ei iiv E..9 a sea i tl 0 3 °a i! I 1 IL j N if i !dl! U ~i hill l• i !ii!I .Y Y A e ee e ase e „ o "i =e i.la!i £ BBeeB 0 0 a 13 Is'10,512 U98Z Nowvq ADMV M W O.LLO 3 , ! 1IN ! E: ~i''~p SIs ~ ~t b N s' N W~ 3 N t N 3 N t B i e! Qi2! ;3aWE2 ease ek E s: • ! P z ' E 1 9, !9 ~ i 5 5 e99 i; a 51i! . 1 9 ! '!5 9 I~ I ~ e 3 I N a i5i g gsj9 NIP" o~ a N Np N wa~ ~w e a 3 e3l~ e a 9 9 s 9E I , 2:9 E 1 P „9; •,9199;: !lelaal is~~dlla 93! ! l9:i, !9I B 6 BB 4 m eej ll'2 N ~9 30 ^ If N fEE 9ljp• rc 3 ~ ! ! j ! 4 i4aea9 aaaaao g N N 3 N 5 i i N alelda5ia5l95aa'S' 3 _ g N + ~D N ; ~ N eead~ 3 0 N N 3e 1 3;i j ~ 4~i'3e3 it ~ f 9'' @. ! i'E~3 '9HES^ ~ai~ld6&s:~i~9 in is • 4 y 6 e i a n ~ M ~ 3 : d 5 ~~3t ZE F : $ f a ~aae- a na~a F i a ~ 6 s ,,,,,,„„m„ aaaaas~omacc9er ~ : f~a®p I- 3wu H°Jtl.LRIHii sx it JH WH.l...,,,,, n N N m at o 1 6 0 lslaip e All a t t a.: 1 a 1 ° Ur 3 tl~i Ell f 3 I !I ~N!l ~~a i x l l t j i ~ 88g'ef~~latr~g8~~ t f 1 t aEE34enai 999999n~vii e I f! o ~ N °t• f1 i It tl!t~i tt o e h1l: !et~t I i}alli o /~l' n Ill~ti 1~!ti! t I~te i}It ii•9°3 t 3~ fl, Ittu ig • si It l~l !t6 ! 31 t 6i•~ i i° lil di lttl lif 1•Iedl i.:!~tf lii t tai p ii a • •o • • oo . •1 p. e e ee ieil W a f a .e i i ~1 9~ f m ~ N to ea l ia3 ''eye! g a °3 ~ 9 i ~yA c.x Aso ~ ~~i °¢a a;g yv® sP a s a IN 'ff aip °ti=E €>1 ail i:t o =a Flieat e,~g~ 2 gg r _ d a a ~ ~xia ~ . o y jpa i ~i59 o ° 7 F f~y~Ytrr a - flYYttr R w . Y 3 E E a•ie ~alla N 4 Q t i!t I! i iie ° i ltllt}i t@ ~31~:!tllat!I:.:c.:¢.tflt o •°y ! li 1; 1; ~t o ;19, ~ li It ~ 1, f•.2r.....l.t!r133333d1t ~ t:i: ~ It~! !tl t •!t !i - ~ ~ e ee a N it! tf" !!tt IH i I{~ t Iii llii~9itE~!a,llf3i3~:fli! r s ~ ` 3i39fei3o4r. m3.3 s.33 q , ~r ~F~T, r . 3F al Le m Sa m .?3g :eae ai 8i a a5~ pa tt!•ai ! i a STREET LIGHTS pe co rodly-~ L ct,- M r F o s -~s to ~e used r eon 204th: Fr©Ot dad-Z& ona ,CX+ 928; 'il s~~t rc m 91 F_vsry @e€v~eer Serfas Cl ~ & Maple j i~ TCMECvL-A ~s ~fCR~TACC IZ,ANC 25 677 Pvjo) 5i C`iG+)5Ob 0-freWbev,rj -rbc jrmeNytho* 1 1101 HERITAGE RANCH 28673 PUJOL STREET (951) 506 2461 I_~ . Remembering the Temecula that was. ATTACHMENT NO.2 STATEMENT OF OPERATION AND STATEMENT OF JUSTIFICATION GAPLANNING\2009\PA09-0101 Baron Heritage Ranch CUP\Planning\OTLRB Staff Report PA09-0101.doc 6 Statement of Operations ❑ Hours and days of operation Open daily 10 A.M. - 5 P.M. Closed Tuesday and Wednesday except by appointment. ❑ Numbers of Employees Owner operated, no additional employees. ❑Average daily peak trips generated Unknown. ❑Type of Equipment or processes used Authentic and period materials used, displayed, and described in an historically sensitive manner. ❑ Description of hazardous materials (existing and new) None ❑ Other Descriptions that effectively describe proposed use Educational facility, interactive historic site, living history place. Statement of Justification 1. Is the site suitable and adequate for the proposed use? Yes. The gentle slopping hillside, and immediate surrounding buildings have a real feel of early Temecula. 2. Would the proposed use and design have a substantial adverse effect on traffic? No, Project is under 5,000 Square feet. 3. Would the proposed use have a substantial adverse impact on the general welfare of persons residing in the community? No. 4. Is the design of the project compatible with the proposed development within the district and it's surroundings? Yes, the Arviso house is already been approved by the city as historically appropriate. SPECIAL EVENTS REPORT CITY OF TEMECULA CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Old Town Local Review Board FROM: Christine Damko, Associate Planner DATE: May 11, 2009 SUBJECT: May Old Town Special Events May 16 and 17 Western Days Western Days include old west skits, high noon shootouts, western music, a working blacksmith, calf roping lessons pony rides, stage coach rides, and a variety of costumed characters. Saturday will feature a Western and Historical art competition and art show presented by the Temecula Valley Art League. Join the cast from the Temecula Gunfighters, numerous visiting gun fighting clubs, and other Old West costumed characters as they perform humorous skits and the high noon shoot out and robbery at The Bank. The weekend events include old west exhibits, western music, Native American exhibits, a Chili Cook-Off on Sunday, and calf roping demonstrations. Hours are 11:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on both days. R:\Old Towv\Spe W Evrnt WLRE M y.d.