HomeMy WebLinkAbout040813 OTLRB Agenda � � In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting,
please contact the office of the City Clerk (951) 694-6444. Notification 48 hours prior to a meeting will enable the
City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to that meeting [28 CFR 35.102.35.104 ADA Title II]
� ;
AGENDA
OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD
GREAT OAK CONFERENCE ROOM
41000 MAIN STREET
April 8, 2013 — 9:00 a.m.
*********
CALL TO ORDER
Roll Call: Board Members: Moore, Puma, Robertson, Watts and Chairman
Blair
PUBLIC COMMENTS
A total of 15 minutes is provided so members of the public may address the Board on items that
are listed on the Agenda. Speakers are limited to three (3) minutes each. If you desire to speak
to the Board about an item not on the Agenda, a green "Request to Speak" form should be
filled out and filed with the Board Secretary.
When you are called to speak, please come forward and state your name for the record.
For all other agenda items a"Request to Speak" form must be filed with the Board Secretary
rior to the Board addressing that item. There is a three (3) minute time limit for individual
speakers.
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
All matter listed under Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and all will be
enacted by one roll call vote. There will be no discussion of these items unless members
of the Local Review Board request specific items to be removed from the Consent
Calendar for separate action. .
CONSENT CALENDAR
1 Minutes
RECOMMENDATION
1.1 Approve the Minutes of January 14, 2013
BOARD BUSINE3S
2 Planninq Application No. PA13-0043, a Minor Modification to chanqe the front fa�ade
and to install outdoor qas fire pits at the Blackbird Tavern, located at 41958 5` Street
�
Applieant: Jill Nelson
28564 Dalton Road
Temecula, CA 92591
Staff: Kenny Taylor
BOARD MEMBERS REPORT
DIRECTOR OF �COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT REPORT
SPECIAL EVENTS REPORT
Springfest Activities
ADJOURNMENT
Next regular meeting: May 13, 2013, 9:00 a.m., Great Oak Conference Room, City Hall, 41000
Main Street, Temecula, CA 92590
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
The agenda packet (including staff reports) will be available for viewing in the Main Reception area at the Temecula
Civic Center (41000 Main Street, Temecula) after 4:00 p.m. the Friday before the Old Town Local Review Board
Meeting. At that time, the packet may also be accessed on the City's website — www.cityoftemecula.orq.
Supplemental material received after the posting of the Agenda
Any supplemental .material distributed to a majoriry of the Board regarding any item on the Agenda, after the posting
of the Agenda, will be available for public review in the Main Reception area at the Temecula Civic Center (41000
Main Street, Temecula), 8:00 a.m. — 5:00 p.m.). In addition, such material will be made available on the City's
website — www.cityoftemecula.orq — and will be available for public review at the respective meeting.
If you have any questions regarding any item of business on the Agenda for this meeting, please call the Planning
Department, (951) 694-6400.
2
ITEM 1
ACTION MINUTES
OLD TOWN TEMECULA LOCAL REVIEW BOARD
GREAT OAK CONFERENCE ROOM
41000 MAIN STREET
January 14, 2013 — 9:00 a.m.
*********
CALL TO ORDER
Roll Call: Board Members: Moore, Puma, Robertson, Watts and Chairman
Blair
ABSENT: WATTS
PUBLIC COMMENTS
A total of 15 minutes is provided so members of the public may address the Board on items that
are listed on the Agenda. Speakers are limited to three (3) minutes each. If you desire to speak
to the Board about an item not on the Agenda, a green "Request to Speak" form should be
filled out and filed with the Board Secretary.
When you are called to speak, please come forward and state your name for the record.
For all other agenda items a"Request to Speak" form must be filed with the Board Secretary
rior to the Board addressing that item. There is a three (3) minute time limit for individual
speakers.
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
All matter listed under Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and all will be
enacted by one roll call vote. There will be no discussion of these items unless members
of the Local Review Board request specific items to be removed from the Consent
Calendar for separate action.
CONSENT CALENDAR
1 Minutes
RECOMMENDATION
1.1 Approve the Minutes of December 10, 2012 APPROVED 3-0-2-0; MOTION BY
BOARD MEMBER PUMA, SECOND BY BOARD MEMBER MOORE; VOTE
RELECTED APPROVAL; WATTS ABSENT, ROBERTSON (ARRIVED
DURING BOARD BUSINESS)
1
BOARD BUSINESS
2 CONTINUED FROM DECEMBER 10. 2012: Receive and file a report on the
remediation plan for the Old Town Temecula Communitv Theater RECEIVE AND FILE
Staff: Dave McBride
BOARD MEMBERS REPORT
DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES REPORT
SPECIAL EVENTS REPORT
ADJOURNMENT
Next regular meeting: February 11, 2013, 9:00 a.m., Great Oak Conference Room, City Hall,
41000 Main Street, Temecula, CA 92590
Albert Blair Patrick Richardson
Chairman Director of Development Services
2
ITEM 2
STAFF REPORT - PLANNING
CITY OF TEMECULA
OLD TOWN LOCAL REVIEW_ BOARD
April 8, 2013
PLANNING APPLICATION NO..PA13-0043
Prepared by: Kenny.Taylor, Project Planner
APPLICATION INFORMATION:
APPLICANT: Jill Nelson
28564 Dalton Road
Temecula, CA 92591
PROPOSAL: A Minor Modification (PA13-0043) to change the front facade and
to install outdoor gas fire pits at the Blackbird Tavern located at
41958 5th Street : .
LOCATION Generally )ocated on the south .side of 5 Street, approximately
175 feet east of Old Town Front Street at 41958 and 41964 5tn
street
._ EXISTING ZONING: OId Town Specific Plan: Downtown Core District (DTC)
SURROUNDING ZONING: North: Downtown Core District (DTC)
South: Downtown Core District (DTC)
East: . Downtown Gore District (DTC).
West: Downtown Core District (DTC) . ..
GENERAL FLAN . �
DESIGNATION: Community Commercial (CC)
EXISTING LAND USE: Restaurant
SURROUNDING LAND
USES: North: Retail, Office, Restaurant; and Residential (DTC)
South:. Retail; Office, and Automotive Repair (DTC)
East: Single Family Home (converted to office) (DTC)
West: Vacant Lot, Restaurant, and Office (DTC)
BACKGROUND
On February 19, 2013, Jill Nelson submitted Planning Application No: PA13-0035, a Minor -
Modificafion to enhance the front facade with a change of materials and to change the exterior
color of the building.
G:\PLANNING\2013\PA13-0043 Blackbird Tavein Facade MOD.\Planning\Old Town Local Review Board\OTLRB.Staff Report.doc
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Analvsis.
The applicant is requesting to modify the exte[ior fa�ade of an existing vacant freestanding
restaurant previously known as Granddad's Hot Dogs (PA11-0042). The building fronts directly
on to 5 Street and is thus highly visible to both motorists and pedestrians.
Since the iocation has previously 6een several differenf restaurants, it has suffered some minor
damage as each tenant applied their own theme to the building: The proposal would unify the
building into a more consistent Western Frontier style design, consistent with the Old Town
Specific Plan. The building currently is based on mid-century architecture.with ranch elements.
The modifications will make the buildings more.internally consistent with design the OId.Town
of Temecula theme. The front building farade wilf include a stucco finish and horizontal
resawn Douglas Fir Planking finish to the middle section of building frontage with. a. trellis
affixed above the building entry displaying. the "Blackbird" lettering for signage. All entry door
and window trims will match the. proposed resawn planking finish. Galvanized goose=neck
lanterns are proposed on fhe upper portion of _the building parapet providing onsite lighting.
The roof overhang to the northwest corner elevation _will retain the -existing galvanized metal
maferial as proposed..
The. color scheme is proposed to consist of Sherwin .Williams. "Black6ean" SW6006, .'in
combination .wifh . unfiinished resawn Douglas Fir; providing visual interesf to the existing
building, The proposed ``Blackbean" color is consistenf with Sherwin Williams Preservation
Palette coloc "Polished Mahogany". Exterior walls. facing the north, south, west, and east
elevations will consist of the proposed `'Blackbean" color.
RECOMMENDATION
The modifications proposed in this application have been determined by staff to be consisfent
with the Old Town Specific.Plan as to building colors and materials: Staff is requesting thaf the
Old Town Local Review Board review, pcovide comments, and recommend approval for this
project. ..
ATTACHMENTS
Proposed Front Facade
Site Rhotos . _ .
G:\PLANNING\2013\PA13-0043 Blackbird Tavern Facade MOD\Planning\Old Town Local Review Board\OTLRB Sfaff Report.doc
PROPOSED FRONT FA�ADE
FRONT FACADE- SKIMCOAT STUCCO MATCH SW 6006 BLACK BEAN (LEFT AND RIGHT SIDES)
FRONT FACADE- RESAWN DUG FIR PLANKING (MIDDLE SECTION)
FRONT FACADE- EXISTING GALVANIZED METAL CORRIGATED ROOFING
FRONT FACADE- GALVANIZED GOOSE-NECK LANTERNS
y �"��'�' ` L �' FRONT FACADE-JOHN TIMBERLAND ELLISON 12 3/4"H BRONZE
�_-�__ ___ OUTDOOR WALL SCONCE (W7803)
�.� __- - FRONT FACADE- ETO MAHOGANY 1, DUAL TEMPERED CLEAR GLASS
_ �� FRENCH DOORS AND SINGLE DOOR (ENERGY STAR RATED)
� - - - - - - � � - - -- - �,�"„►,,;, � I'il"'9!�l��I'��ll!{I����(��
: T . : _ , � .� �
- .� -_ -. �
, _ ;-- ,_-_- ,
-- �_ -- - _ _ _�_ _ ,
� �
��- - �
_ _ �' -
- - � ---
-� �, ---- -
SITE PHOTOS
_� � ., � � � . - � . . _ ` -- - �
. � .�.,.�,. _ � � " -
. _ __ - - � ._ ', .
� ; . � � - � � '' - ° -� '�
_ I .
� � � R_ �, - � � t
� �1
� � � [
k� I •
, s ; .� �,'�.� � -- — 9S6Tb - -
v � � , ,�.
� f� �� �}':� ., , � � , - - _ _ ..
� r ., , � �r
.� � �_}, � �,f� i � �� ( ;
� � . "�` � �_ - !� �� ., ��:
�.
7�-.:�!�� � �� � Z��' QK y�� ' :t
��,� ---- -
�.
.
��. ' �
•� .:
i .
` .�
� �
��. `
. - r � .
c w.
. ' ,���.� �� _
'-.2..'�� �
�
� '" �
. � _.
.. , _ ti- .. _ '
f. _
7 ,
`� ���. � �.��.�.� •
f.� _. �l
a
b'
.r T �
1 �
,�--- nr
� ' `�� _
,' '; � ��o ;��.---,�.,�� �//� _ _.
_ ;�� \����\�, ���.�� �"`;
,
� \ � ,� , - ,
,
. r I � ,�� ;�`, . . _" . �
� � ,A AV ' V �� r
� � ` 1 �
�\ v�� '�A � ��� � �� , �, -
� `
�� ��\�� �� �;� � � ' . ,�� �,
\� � , , ,, �, ,,�
� ,� � w �� �V��,, � �r
��° ��,��� ��,�
_ �,. � . :
y J � - '" � , �� s �'�p` _ . � I
- � z °�
� ,! }. � • ..,,. -�� =-'�,: �. #
� " > ' � �?� „g - I�
, �.r� �: - I
.. �. - �
. �_. �
�t�:�;,
- r . � '
. ,. , � � _ L ���� .' ,
�
- . J;
.. . - . �,'1u ��^,1
. . . ... � �� k �. n 7 . � - i �j
3' -
... � . - � 7 �-�-�. `IR 1
.. _ }_ ���� '
.. . � . " - - �=� W ��:� 3.
. .. ' .. . . r i
i
' ��
�
� � f �.__._r-------- ..�— .,-_.-�-.�
; f -- � -
,-'f.�;
_� .. s ��� }
ti _ , � ` t• � � , pi��.:.
_ � __ _ ����;� � JI�
� _. . _ _- - — I : (
� �"�� `��;
,� .,�� _;�f ,
; � �-. :%�J:�r
,
�, !�' r ; �'' ' � t `"' ;,�;'
„ .. •, � ..
. r .
•,i ; �w• ; �.
- ,
� . • ,tr. .�/
-- ---.-. � ; }:,,,�;#'
i � �.-
I �,'' �+• y '
� �! � ' .
f � , `
. _ . ...._—. � :. r E.
��• •
y Y ��� �
y.V �
� .
�� �
_ . . . _ .. .. . . , . _ .. ., �4
'�'`y ' 3�
`��. �
. ►f,`� ' ''t � � `� � �' �� y
♦ ^Ar
�c f �
+ � 'f ✓ '�;�
� '� ` ` I I
� � . � - Y
� r -
t
li
"-�� fl
{, ' �. �
� � �� ;'
���
�� �' .f
� n
4
I
• • `4
� � �
l � �• - • � �
r
� � �♦ .
, �
� .�
' ` �
� ,
- �
�
/ /
A
�1..
I _ `�'`� . _ . � ' ' • �/ _
.�-: .
- •. � .•,
� � .�. ` . �+' � " � : - - _ s
A �Le.A � :z �• � , y --- � = . � '�`'� „x�,- 3
i
;� • � ' ��'� - '"� •, 1 :�; 4� .y � � �6
� � � � �. v . ` {f � � � `��
- •�� ..:�.� � �� ..
, P , �ln - x�.�c� �'- „ ..fi . .
. ••N � t s� , ..���d� ./��
, y' � _--__ t r ` � f ^ f �
. . ��� �-�i , X ' . � .�
_� ,�'u �" y . ! ' �r^°-/
a,,.;., s
. '� R� �" � y �. � - - - .
- . . M1' �� � �; � .' 7 _ � � , . . 11 .'�Y� d- 'µ � � �� � ,� . .
� � p, i - . `" � �' ` �` ' .
('�` � ti� ya�"i , t� - �„� �� y ti ' �# y �
� i • a " ��� '� ,
� �: - ¢3� r � 15 �� � , p ��, '
� ,� � _ . ,, �
f '�� ...�y �.�,��,.; , %!
1 i ' � i . . _ � sT.._ �' ���.
� �_ ,..,. � � § ��� �, �.
� � `�'�� �'�' "�',r ,.;�' '•� ° I
- � � ' �.t 1 �s; � Y . .
z' _ - ��� � �`��`" .
� � S� r-u�- 1 "�" s � - � s rc r+� `�Y � _ � � ;' ' � , . ._
� .. . �'� . �. '''�° ° ��,� .�,,.� ....a i ' -
,,, �• . a' .'s}� .z �a.r:�
� - -��;, � `. � '� .£, , ' i_
' � `.`.'� ` -�^ ,
`: _ fi' ` � '
�' 'i+' �t. ' , - �_
� F � tl-
/ - �" y ,. � � _ +
' .. ��,. �F" ` � _ -
/ , y ' �� Y � I t � , � Y•;` �
� � c ' ,. -
�� � � � i. � ��-w. �
�.rt �. ,
, ..} .�i;:.. � ',.. 1 ��� �;y� � i ��
� , a �
� .. � .+A �� �,� � . �
,� 4'�� i �1 �i� J� dr�iK. tti 4:",, .,�R, - � ' i �� :?
= �'`�' C{ ' +� ; ^ � � �.��,
. �`. �, �
�� � � - . �� . {� F'; - a � � ��.'"+�%-, T � ^ . . .
'�' . [�; ' �''/� 1 : E { �',�-'"� � • �� �'!i'f�.- ' .
' �t � � ,� �.�'��. � ` � r'�E � ' . � - � `� ..
. _, _ , � 4 ���`q. 1
, c o-, �:G�. ,:` o
� �� � i r�. � y � .. :" � Y. � , ` .
f
�: a �,� • k � X Y � ;
� � � 'R�d
' ri...w�! f .. ,�, �, ' ' r y� �� 4r s ' ='� � � "
.' '�`�, ' �� c
� � _—. � •^� ' �� .�•� t� ; � ti ��_ + �.y��. '.
. � r ,, ..i4 "�. i� � : ti
_ yi��. t �" ...f •, �. .
;1 . i S � '�� tl� l� . �
i ��y ��,��, ' �� ,.'� �'� � �"'� �r';.�. i
.� h � r � '�'.� ' . I � I
J' . ! i s 1. � , . :� I
� �. �i+� * rfk +�� I
�A� ..��.. � � J � A ' ^ J !` � � .J �
� ,.'� ' "� ` �- f� �
. > : ' • i'� # * z .� ��P
, >� '`
�: �• ,:
.� .� t � � y � `�
� � , � V • y � j f �
n r y . �..� � ?`� � ( •� . � t
� � ° � ' � 4 , t . � y M` ��+ � �! ^T
r { I , M. � � . ���� �.
.Jl ' ��� y � � ,
r . � tk -- � • e ' �. ;�.�. �� t r�. � � �.� :��f � ♦
� ' . � � ' • �.. ��1� i�'-' ,
� . . I � ;,�r ,' � ��S .
:
� . . _ _ f � � � ''' .. . �-.
.. ' � "�.y � �'��� I'�' 1 �-'� � �I
. ��:�' l � �,w � At � ��i 1
� �
� ' � . T � 1 ' , . �� .�,; ��'• ���j� �� T � J
_ �� : ��: , . �''� ��'
,, � �,
,�4 '^ *�,�
. �! .� ,
'i� ::� ��+
. .. .. .. . . � . . . _ �' F � . . ��` �4 �.. .. �IM�