HomeMy WebLinkAbout061394 OTLRB Minutes OLD TOWN TEMECULA
HISTORICAL PRESERVATION DISTRICT
LOCAL REVIEW BOARD
Regular Meeting
June 13, 1994
Members present: Walt Allen, Larry Markham, Bob Morris,
Bob Lord, Bob Gotham and Bill Harker.
Staff present : Matthew Fagan and Dave Hogan.
The meeting was called to order at 9:05 by Walt Allen in the Board Room of the
Community Center, 28B16 Pujol St., Temecula, Ca.
Following the Agenda:
1. There was no public comment.
2. The minutes of the May 9,1994 meeting were approved as written.
To accommodate staff and petitioners agenda was revised as follows:
3. Dave Hogan passed out outlines and advised board members of board
responsibilities pursuant to the adopted Old Town Temecula Specific Plan. Dave
also solicited comments concerning the safety rails(pedestrian) for the First
Street bridge. After some discussion, the Board recommended that the needed
rails problem be referred to Public Works Staff for recommendations as to design.
Motion to refer by Walt Allen; second by R. Lord, carried unanimously.
4. Owners/operators of Mad Madelines (Hamburger Restaurant) petitioned approval
of paint colors (already in place) for their shop. Board decided to table
approval pending outcome of Texas Lil's color change. Motion Harker; 2nd Gotham,
approval unanimous.
5. Golor palette w~s distributed by Matthew Fagan during discussion of Mad
Madelines color scheme. Walt Allen commented that colors should not be limited
to one manufacturer/retailer of paints, but should allow for competitive pricing
6. Latest Museum drawings and color samples were submitted by architect Russell
Rumansoff. He also stated that exterior stone veneer would be local granite and
that doors planned for the museum would be of wood but that windows were planned
for aluminum(baked enamel or anodized finish). Colors, roof material, stucco
and stone veneer were unanimously approved, but doors and windows came under
further discussion. Bob Sorham suggested that Museum Board/architect consider
exterior metal clad wooden doors and windows for, at least, the rotunda area.
Russell requested that plastic windows (painted to simulate wood) be considered
for the balance of the building, as the eye would relate the plastic to actual
wood from observation distance. He was invited to attend the next meeting with
pictures and/or samples of the actual material to be used. Bob Gorham suggested
that he could furnish a catalog of windows and doors to allow agreement between
the board and museum. Bob Lord suggested that if windows appear from viewing
distance to be what might have been used during the target era, that should
satisfy requirements.
7. Board review of projects.
a. Butterfield Square signs. Bob Lord stepped down from Board position and
presented petition for approval of three different signs on the Butterfield
Square property, as follows:
1. Use raised wood letters on face of Butterfield Square building on North side
facing Third St.
2. Install THE (heart graphic> OF OLDTOWN on freestanding Sign at Corner
Front/Third. This would replace OLD TOWN TEMECULA MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION on
tenant pylon section.
3. Install additional 12"x52" hanging sign at rear of pole sign at front of
property.
Lord excused himself' from the room to allow deliberation on his request. A
discussion was held on the large wood letters sign<SHOPS) and it was determined
to be legal as far as percent of wall area occupied by sign. Appears to be in
line with design specs. Approved with flat, rather than gloss paint.
2. Proposal with wood letters<no plastic) non-gloss paint approved.
3. The jewelry sign itself was approved, but a question was raised regarding
additions to a non-conforming free standing pole sign. Hanging jewelry sign
where proposed was rejected and City will be asked to reconsider approving free
standing pole signs with reasonable heighth restrictions.
Bm
Status report.
a. Letter to oldtowners. Approved by board.
b. Camera bug paint. Owner has agreed to change to palette approved color
by the end of the month.
c. Ron Walton-no show.
d. building and safety-no action.
e. museum update-see above.
f. Zev Buffman-no new news.
9. Board discussion-no time.
10. Walk thru Oldtown-no time.
11. On motion by Dill Harker, seconded by Walt Allen, board moved to adjourn
at 11:40 AM.
Respectfully submitted,
R. Lord, recording secretary.
CC: Planning Dept., all board members.